| Emerson College pollster Spencer Kimball also highlighted challenges measuring turnout interest: | Turnout is a moving target; enthusiasm expressed in polls doesn’t necessarily translate to turnout on Election Day. … Record Hispanic turnout exceeded our expectations, but most of the polling caught the Hispanic swing for Democrats by almost 2:1. | | | | Marist Poll director Barbara Carvalho highlighted that the blue wave narrative was rooted in polls: | The blue wave narrative was an early and consistent theme this fall with polls simply differing on the magnitude of Democratic support. That difference was likely based on the degree to which methods included previous turnout estimates … less dependence on previous elections, wider margins. | | | | BlueLabs vice president of polling Joy Wilke highlighted the role of irregular voters: | Infrequent voters have swung dramatically since 2024; in ’24 they broke for Trump by 7-8 points, but in ’26, they broke for the Democrats by 16 pts. That’s a huge shift! And while these infrequent voters are decisive for elections, they’re also really hard to reach! | | | | Atlas Intel CEO Andrei Roman criticized some pollsters for not recognizing a “wave” election: | AtlasIntel polls were balanced in terms of underestimating or overestimating Democrats and Republicans. … Thinking about polls more broadly and not just AtlasIntel polls, most pollsters did indeed massively underestimate Democrats because they missed the basic fact that this was a wave election. This was probably due to poor modeling of turnout by partisanship and race (Democrats and Latinos mobilized much above the average of other groups) but also by age (young voter mobilization) and the swing in the independent vote. | | | | The full picture of turnout will become clear in the coming months as states update their rolls to identify whether every single registered voter turned out. By matching poll respondents to these files, pollsters will be able to assess whether different likely voter models would have better captured the 2026 electorate. ‘Recalled vote’ weighting ranged widely Weighting poll samples to reflect the results of the most recent presidential election was credited with reducing error in 2024 election polling, but pollsters used widely varying approaches to doing so this fall. One approach used by Post-Schar School polls and Marist polls is to ask respondents how they voted in 2024 and weight the sample of registered voters to match 2024 turnout and vote choice. YouGov’s panel-based polls relied on reported vote choice closer to the 2024 election and combined this with a statistical model of the overall population of registered voters. New York Times-Siena College polls use “synthetic past vote,” which combines self-reported support for Trump and Kamala Harris with statistically modeled estimate of support among other 2024 voters. And Fox News’s polling team “monitored 2024 vote recall and when it went beyond a certain range they partially weighted back to 2024 results,” according to a spokesperson. Each of the above polls weighted samples of registered voters to match 2024 results, then used turnout indicators to produce likely voter estimates for 2026. Kimball said Emerson College polls “weighted the sample to general voter targets including a split electorate in the national 2024 popular vote, then [applied] a LV model that allows non-2024 voters to fall naturally.” Their final national poll this year had Harris voters outnumbering Trump voters by two points among likely voters. AtlasIntel weighted likely voter estimates to targets for the share of Trump and Harris voters it expected in 2026. In an email to The Post, CEO Andrei Roman said “the in-depth modeling of turnout is AtlasIntel intellectual property.” Did recalled vote weighting work in 2026? Pollsters gave mixed answers to this question, although some said they are still analyzing the results. Survey160 pollsters Kevin Collins and Alejandro Frydman found that weighting registered-voter samples by recalled vote increased accuracy dramatically in three of four states where the firm conducted late polls, while slightly reducing accuracy in a fourth state. AtlasIntel’s Roman said “It helped. It always helps.” Barbara Carvalho of Marist said the group is still evaluating the impact of the 2024 vote, but her “first glance is it helped in some states and not in others.” The pattern was similar in a preliminary analysis of Post-Schar School state and congressional district polls. But in a post-election analysis last week, Quantus Insights lead pollster Jason Corley said weighting to recalled vote was counterproductive: | The out-party’s low-propensity voters, the ones the voter file says probably won’t show, show up. And the in-party’s softer voters stay home or quietly drift in the last two weeks. Every tool we use to make a sample look like an electorate pushes against both of those. A likely-voter screen built on past turnout can’t see a surge electorate, because by definition those people didn’t vote last time. Anchoring on 2024 presidential recall pulls the sample toward an electorate that didn’t come back. | | | | How do pollsters judge the performance of midterm election polls this year? Rivers (YouGov): “Okay, not great. While we underestimated the size of the blue wave, nobody paying attention to the polls should have been surprised that there was a blue wave.” Carvalho (Marist): “Excellent. Polls provided a solid narrative regarding the intensity and motivation of voters to support Democratic candidates along with the context that neither political party nor their nominees were particularly popular.” Kimball (Emerson): “Good. They captured the broader trends and signaled where a Democratic wave could make races competitive.” Democrats renew faith in democracy, while Republicans lose it — In August, 73 percent of Republicans in an Economist-YouGov poll said democracy was working at least “somewhat well” in the United States compared with only 23 percent of Democrats. After last week’s midterm elections, Democratic faith in American democracy jumped to 44 percent while Republicans’ dropped to 51 percent. Read more. |